Christian Mingle vs eharmony: Best Christian Dating App in 2024

Published: June 16, 2022
Updated: June 20, 2022
christian mingle vs eharmony considered by faithful couple

Finding the dating app that best fits your Christian values can improve your chances of meeting the right person. Christian Mingle and eharmony are both popular with Christian singles looking to make a meaningful connection, in terms of love and faith.. 

Find out which one is best suited to your dating needs. See how features and prices compare between the two dating apps.

Table of contents [ Show Hide ]

Picking the right dating app: Christian Mingle vs eharmony

The right dating app for you will be the one that most closely matches your faith and life goals. Dating apps are a bit like Holy Bible translations, everyone has a favourite.

Online dating app recommendations

Before you pick your favourite, be sure to have a look at our dating app recommendations

Christian dating recommendations

Check out our top recommendations for the leading Christian dating sites:

Most Popular Choice
Christian Mingle vs eharmony: Best Christian Dating App in [year]
  • Most common dating platorm in the US
  • Great matching system
  • Zero negative review
Christian Mingle vs eharmony: Best Christian Dating App in [year]
  • Large database of verified & attractive Asian and European singles
  • Efficient communication and instant messaging 
  • Top-level safety and professional support
Christian Mingle vs eharmony: Best Christian Dating App in [year]
  • Meet real asian, european, and latino singles
  • Real-time communication with efficient tools
  • Professional dating services
Christian Mingle vs eharmony: Best Christian Dating App in [year]
Meet and hook-up with neighbors. Search and view specific profiles in your area. Male profiles needed.
  • Free and easy registration.
  • Largest verified database in the US.
  • Thousands sign up every day.
  • Male profiles needed.
  • Guaranteed matches.
Christian Mingle vs eharmony: Best Christian Dating App in [year]
Christian Filipina is perfect for people who are looking for a serious relationship.
  • 24 hrs customer service
  • One on one Romance Consultations.
  • 100% real users.

Christian Mingle vs eharmony: where are they different? 

Here are the most important differences between Christian Mingle and eharmony.

Christian Mingleeharmony
Who is it for?Christian singles looking for a partner that shares their faith and values.Singles looking for serious dating and even marriage.
Registration detailsProfile creation process based on honesty that helps you get matched with compatible profiles.In-depth registration process focussed on building a compatibility profile. SMS profile verification.
Memberships and profilesThere are 16 million profiles on Christian Mingle and 3 million active monthly users. 10 million users have profiles on eharmony.
Premium ServiceFree trial does not allow you to message first. Paid plans are available.Sign up is free but most features like messaging or viewing photos require paid membership.
ProsApproachable features and app design facilitates Christian dating.Advanced matchmaking technology means you get curated profiles based on compatibility.
ConsYou need to pay to send the first message to someone you match with.It’s more expensive than competitors. Free accounts are very limited.

How is Christian Mingle better than eharmony?

While some dating apps allow you to search profiles by faith, Christian Mingle is designed from the ground up to serve the Christian singles community. It offers a basic feature set to start dating online with faith-based purpose.

As opposed to eharmony, Christian Mingle gives you free will when it comes to searching and browsing through profiles. You are not forced to choose from a curated selection. This gives you control in terms of choosing profiles to like or interact with.

christian mingle vs eharmony app screenshots


These are the core features on Christian Mingle:

LookBook is a Tinder-like interface where you browse through profile cards one at a time. So with Christian Mingle you don’t have to move heaven and earth to get different ways of browsing through profiles.

Christian Mingle strikes a balance between features, convenience, and pricing. If faith-first dating is important to you, then this is the better option for meeting Christian singles.

How is eharmony better than Christian Mingle?

Unlike Christian Mingle, eharmony collects as much information as it can, to provide the most compatible matches. The way that eharmony is able to collect this data is through a detailed personality questionnaire. This helps its advanced matchmaking technology not only match users effectively but also show how any two profiles are compatible.

While eharmony was started by a devout Christian psychologist, the app isn’t solely focussed on faith-based dating. Many Christian singles have found success on eharmony because its focus on committed relationships and marriage is a common goal for all Christians.

Additionally, eharmony will take your Christian faith into account when figuring out how compatible you are with someone else on the app.

If you are looking for a serious relationship, then eharmony is a great option as long as you are willing to spend more money on online dating. Your experience on eharmony starts with a dating personality quiz. This is an opportunity to reflect on your relationship goals and the sort of person you want to be with. 

christian mingle vs eharmony app screenshot comparison

Since eharmony’s matchmaking technology does the heavy lifting when it comes to finding compatible profiles, the rest of the app is user-friendly in terms of design and layout. When you look at someone’s profile on eharmony, you will have a compatibility score embedded on the top left corner of their profile picture. 

What is impressive is the detail that eharmony provides when it comes to compatibility. On eharmony, you can drill down and see what areas you have in common and where you differ. This includes core values and traits like faith, communication, lifestyle, and emotional intelligence.

Did you know?

Christian Mingle vs eharmony: which one is cheaper?

Christian Mingle is cheaper than eharmony. Additionally, Christian Mingle also offers a month-to-month paid option for those who don’t want to pay upfront for a longer period of time. Take a look at the price breakdown below.

Christian Mingle Paid Planseharmony Premium
3 months$24.99 per monthn/a
6 months$22.99 per month$65.90 per month
12 months$14.99 per month$45.90 per month
24 monthsn/a$35.90 per month

It’s worth bearing in mind that eharmony does offer regular promotions that slash its pricing by up to 50%, which then puts it much closer to how much Christian Mingle costs. Since price is not the only factor to how good an app is for faith-based dating, let’s take a closer look at the features.

Free vs paid features: how do these apps stack up?

Christian Mingle vs eharmony bring different approaches to their dating app services. Let’s take a closer look at what each one offers to its free and premium users.

Christian Mingle features: free vs paid options

Check out all the Christian Mingle features and compare the free and paid versions side-by-side.

Christian Mingle free featuresChristian Mingle premium features
✅ Create a profile with 6 photos.✅ Create a profile with 6 photos.
✅ Search for profiles across all of Christian Mingle.✅ Search for profiles across all of Christian Mingle.
✅ Receive matches and notifications.✅ Receive matches and notifications.
✅ Limited messaging.✅ Messaging+ allows you to contact any Christian Mingle member.
✅ Read and reply to all messages
✅ Read receipts
✅ Browse anonymously
✅ Extra privacy options to hide your profile.

Christian Mingle offers enough features for free users to get a good feel for the app. However, you do need to pay to get the most out of Christian Mingle. The good news is that you don’t need to commit to long subscription plans since you have the option to just pay for one month.

Just make sure you remember to cancel or turn off auto-renewal in your app settings at least one day before your subscription ends.

eharmony features: free vs paid options

Check out all the eharmony features and compare the free and paid versions side-by-side.

eharmony free featureseharmony premium features
✅ Create a profile✅ Create a profile
✅ Unlimited matches✅ Unlimited matches
✅ Send Smiles, Icebreakers, and Greetings✅ Send Smiles, Icebreakers, and Greetings
✅ Limited messaging✅ Unlimited messaging
✅ Video Date chat feature
✅ View unlimited photos
✅ See who has visited you
✅ Access to distance search filter
✅ Detailed personality profile results

It’s clear that to get even just the bare minimum out of eharmony you need to pay for the service. The free version lets you create a profile and send reactions to other users but, beyond that, communication is heavily limited to occasional promotional weekends where sending messages is free. 

To have meaningful conversations with your eharmony matches a paid account is required. When you pay for eharmony, you also get access to video chat features as well as being able to see who has viewed your profile.

Which dating app is better for you? Christian Mingle vs eharmony

See what the pros and cons of Christian Mingle vs eharmony are, so you can decide which app is better for you.

Christian Mingle pros and cons

These are the advantages and disadvantages of the Christian Mingle dating app.

✅ Focus on Christian faith-based dating.❌ Not many innovative features.
✅ Flexible and simplified features.❌ Not a good option for casual dating.
✅ Affordable pricing

eharmony pros and cons

These are the advantages and disadvantages of the eharmony dating app.

✅ Advanced matchmaking technology.❌ Expensive when compared with competition.
✅ User base is primarily looking for serious relationships. ❌ Limited profile search options.
✅ Clear layout and app design.

Christian Mingle vs eharmony: final thoughts

Both Christian Mingle and eharmony are great options for dating online. Which one you choose depends on whether your priority is to match only with other Christian singles. Both apps focus on fostering meaningful and committed relationships, but only Christian Mingle is exclusively designed for faith-based dating. 

Christian Mingle gives the user a lot of control in terms of how they browse through profiles. On the other hand, eharmony wants you to do the work upfront through its personality questionnaire to be better able to leverage its matchmaking technology as you use the dating app.

If cost is a concern for you, then Christian Mingle is the better option since it’s more affordable. However, eharmony does regularly run promotions and discounts. The other way that eharmony provides more value for money than Christian Mingle is through its extensive premium features, which include video chat.

Both dating apps are established and have good reputations.  If you’re undecided, why not try both?

Christian Mingle vs eharmony FAQ

You can find answers to common Christian Mingle vs eharmony questions below.

Is Christian Mingle better than eharmony?

Christian Mingle is better than eharmony for those who are solely looking for faith-based dating to match with Christian singles. Eharmony is better if you want to invest in your love life, value compatibility and advanced matchmaking features to find that special someone.

Is eharmony legit?

Eharmony is definitely a legitimate dating app. Eharmony was founded by a Christian clinical psychologist who was interested in relationships and compatibility. Even though eharmony’s founder has been upfront about his faith and beliefs, the dating app is designed for a broad audience looking for a serious dating app.

Which dating app will help me get married, Christian Mingle vs eharmony?

Both apps will help you get married because they focus on serious relationships and tying the knot. They do this differently: Christian Mingle focuses on connecting you with other Christians, while eharmony aims at finding compatible singles who have the same relationship goals as you.

Which is cheaper: Christian Mingle vs eharmony?

Christian Mingle is clearly cheaper than eharmony. However, if you are looking for a dating app that recommends profiles based on advanced matchmaking and compatibility based technology then eharmony is the top option.