Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles compared: Pick the best

Published: March 19, 2022
Updated: August 18, 2023
plenty of fish vs elitesingles

Finding the best dating app for you increases the opportunities of getting matched with the right person online. Plenty Of Fish, POF for short, and EliteSingles both have dating apps so that iPhone and Android users can access their dating services. Let’s take a look at how the two apps compare and their features, before you make a choice.

Table of contents [ Show Hide ]

Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles: Differences

These are the key differences between Plenty Of Fish and EliteSingles.

Plenty Of FishEliteSingles
Who is it for?Diverse users looking for casual or serious dating.Ambitious professionals looking for serious relationships.
Registration detailQuick registration process, lets you add details later.Thorough profile creation based on honesty to help get matched with compatible profiles.
Memberships and profilesPlenty Of Fish has 150 million registered users. Profiles are of varying quality.5+ million users, high-quality profiles thanks to strict verification.
Premium ServiceMain features are available for free, including messaging.Free service doesn’t include messaging, several subscription plan options, more perks the longer you subscribe.
ProsFreedom to tailor profile searches with deep filtering options.Affordable and flexible pricing and plans, along with an active and educated user base.
ConsSome profiles are misleading or fraudulent.You need the premium account to get anything out of it.

How is Plenty Of Fish better than EliteSingles?

Plenty Of Fish gives you more control than EliteSingles when browsing through profiles. You tailor your searches to fit your needs. Plenty Of Fish offers robust filtering options so you can be as specific or as broad as you need to be when you’re searching.

plenty of fish vs elitesingles features for plenty of fish

It’s in the brand name, there are plenty of fish in the sea, POF’s approach to dating is all about abundance, from features to the millions of registered users. There is no shortage of ways to meet people. This means that there is no one specific way to use Plenty Of Fish successfully.

Plenty Of Fish is great if you are looking for a flexible and feature-rich dating app. If you like to be proactive when looking for someone to date, then POF is the choice for you.

Did you know?

Plenty Of Fish has an app for iPhone and Android as well as one for iPads. That version of the app is designed with the larger screen in mind, making it more convenient to browse through profiles with ease.

How is EliteSingles better than Plenty Of Fish

EliteSingles takes quality over quantity to heart by making compatibility between matches a priority. The app calculates an easy-to-understand compatibility percentage based on the qualities you’re looking for as well as your own background, preferences and values.

If you’re too busy to be looking through hundreds of profiles or creating complex search filters, you’ll enjoy using EliteSingles. This is why EliteSingles is aimed at well-educated and career-focused professionals who don’t have time to spend on a dating app.

plenty of fish vs elitesingles features for elitesingles

The EliteSingles tagline is “Date smarter, not harder”. Since ‘time is money’, the app does the work and selects compatible matches for you to check out every day. If you want a long-term committed relationship but don’t want to waste time online, then EliteSingles is going to be the better choice for you. 

Did you know?

Over 85% of EliteSingles members hold college or advanced degrees. While anyone over 18 can join the app, most EliteSingles users are over 30 years old.

Picking the best dating app: Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles 

The dating apps you choose to be on can either help or hinder your relationship or intimacy goals. It’s important to pick the right dating app to make sure you have the best chance of matching with someone who is compatible with your love life preferences.

Which dating app you sign up to is a personal choice, like your favorite fast food. This is why we recommend having a look at more than one option before signing up.

Have a look at our dating app recommendations to help you find the one that’s the best fit for you.

Most Popular Choice
Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles compared: Pick the best
  • Most popular dating app in US
  • 100% match assured
  • Numerous positive reviews
Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles compared: Pick the best
  • Meet real asian, european, and latino singles
  • Real-time communication with efficient tools
  • Professional dating services
Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles compared: Pick the best
Meet and hook-up with neighbors. Search and view specific profiles in your area. Male profiles needed.
  • Free and easy registration.
  • Largest verified database in the US.
  • Thousands sign up every day.
  • Male profiles needed.
  • Guaranteed matches.
Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles compared: Pick the best
Christian Filipina is perfect for people who are looking for a serious relationship.
  • 24 hrs customer service
  • One on one Romance Consultations.
  • 100% real users.
Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles compared: Pick the best
  • Large database of verified & attractive Asian and European singles
  • Efficient communication and instant messaging 
  • Top-level safety and professional support

Which dating app is cheaper: Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles

Plenty Of Fish is cheaper than EliteSingles. Its pricing is also simpler with only one premium tier while EliteSingles has two paid options. Have a look at the price differences below.

Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles price comparison

Both dating apps have 3,6, and 12 month subscription options. Take a look at the price differences.

Plenty Of Fish UpgradeEliteSingles Premium Plans
3 months$21.32 per month$34.95 per month
6 months$15.99 per month$19.95 per month
12 months$10.66 per month$17.95 per month

The Plenty Of Fish upgrade is noticeably cheaper than EliteSingles, especially at the 3 and 12 month subscriptions. If you are looking to save money, then POF is clearly the more affordable choice here.

Free and paid features: Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles

Plenty Of Fish and EliteSingles segment their features differently depending on whether you are using a free version or sign up for a paid subscription.

Plenty Of Fish features: free vs paid options

Check out all the Plenty Of Fish features and compare the free and paid versions side-by-side.

Plenty Of Fish free featuresPlenty Of Fish “Upgrade” paid features
✅ Create a profile✅ Create a profile
✅ Add 8 photos✅ Add 16 photos to your profile
✅ View main profiles✅ View a user’s extended profile
✅ Send and receive messages✅ Send and receive messages
✅ No ads
✅ Read receipts
✅ “Triple your views” monthly boost
✅ Your profile shows up in top search results
✅ See when someone views your profile
✅ Priority access to Meet Me feature

Plenty Of Fish gives its free users all the core features needed to start dating online: profile creation, viewing other profiles and messaging other users they are interested in.

The paid features improve the experience by increasing the number of photos you can add to your profile and how much you see when viewing someone else’s profile. The rest of the paid features range from quality-of-life improvements, like no ads, to features that improve your chances of matching, such as view boosts and priority access.

The key thing to remember is that Plenty Of Fish isn’t stopping you from matching or talking with someone, just because you are using the free version. Paying for the perks remains an option for those who want them.

EliteSingles features: free vs paid options

Elite features are divided up between a free version and paid options with different subscription periods. Take a look at what option has the features that are important to you.

Free optionPremium Light (3 months)Premium Classic & Comfort (6 & 12 months)
✅ Profile creation✅ Profile creation✅ Profile creation
✅ Unlimited messaging✅ Unlimited messaging
✅ View profile details✅ View profile details
✅ Intelligent matchmaking✅ Intelligent matchmaking
✅ View all profile photos
✅ See who visited your profile 
✅ Read receipts

The free option on EliteSingles is not worth discussing since it only allows for profile creation and browsing obscured profiles. The Premium Light 3-month option enables all the features you would get for free on Plenty Of Fish. 

For actual premium features, you want to look at the Premium Classic or Comfort. These two options actually have cheaper monthly rates, although they do require you to subscribe for a longer period of time (6 or 12 months).

Which dating app is better for you? Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles

Here are the pros and cons for Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles to help you decide which app is better.

Plenty Of Fish pros and cons

These are the advantages and disadvantages of the Plenty Of Fish dating app.

✅ Key features unlocked for free users❌ Not all profiles are high quality
✅ Affordable paid upgrade❌ Users have to sort through profiles to find a good match
✅ 4.2 out of 5 App Store review score

EliteSingles pros and cons

These are the benefits and drawbacks of using the EliteSingles dating app.

✅ Quality over quantity approach❌ You need to pay for basic features
✅ Focus on serious relationships❌ 3.1 out of 5 App Store review score
✅ Intelligent matchmaking technology helps you find compatible profiles❌ Fewer users than Plenty Of Fish

Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles Final thoughts

When comparing Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles, one thing to keep in mind that both apps are well established. Your choice between the two apps comes down to the following factors:

If you want to use a free dating service, then Plenty Of Fish is the best dating app for you. Its free features are everything you need to start dating online. Plenty Of Fish is also great if you like to browse through profiles or refine your searches.

If your online dating goal is to find a long-term partner, then EliteSingles is a better fit. While you need to pay for EliteSingles to be usable, its intelligent matchmaking features will do most of the work and show you the most compatible profiles every day.

Plenty Of Fish vs EliteSingles FAQ

Here are answers to common questions about Plenty Of Fish vsEliteSingles.

Is EliteSingles better than POF?

EliteSingles is better than POF if you are looking for a committed relationship and don’t want to spend time sorting through profiles. For casual dating or if you’re unsure about the sort of relationship you are looking for, then POF is a better fit.

Is EliteSingles legit?

EliteSingles is definitely a legitimate dating app. The dating service has been around for many years and is part of Spark Networks, one of the largest companies in online dating. EliteSingles has robust online security policies to make sure user profiles are valid.

Which dating app will help me get married, EliteSingles or Plenty Of Fish?

EliteSingles is potentially more likely to help you tie the knot because of its focus on traditional relationships. That doesn’t mean you can’t find the love of your life on Plenty Of Fish. As long as you’re up front about what you’re looking for, you definitely can. However, you may also come across people who don’t share your relationship goals.

Which is cheaper: EliteSingles vs POF?

POF is cheaper than EliteSingles. This is because all the main dating features on Plenty Of Fish are available for free. On EliteSingles, you need to pay to be able to send messages and properly view profiles.

Dating apps compared

Check out our dating app comparisons so you can pick the best one for you.